How Many Trading Pins Should You Order for a Tournament? (Complete Guide for Teams)

If your team is preparing for a tournament, one question always comes up

How many trading pins should we order?

It’s a simple question but getting it wrong can affect your entire tournament experience. Order too few, and players run out early. Order too many, and you end up overspending.
If you’re just getting started, check out our Custom Trading Pins options to see what’s possible.
This guide breaks it down clearly so you can choose the right quantity based on your team size, tournament type, and trading activity.

Why Trading Pins Are a Big Deal at Tournaments

At youth tournaments across the United States, trading pins are more than just souvenirs, they’re part of the culture.
Players trade pins to connect with teams from different regions, compare designs, and build memories off the field.
Teams often invest in baseball trading pins for major tournaments where trading is most active.
At larger events like Cooperstown, trading happens daily, and teams with standout pins often attract more attention.
That’s why ordering the right number of pins is important, not just for quantity, but for the overall experience.

How Many Trading Pins Per Player?

The simplest way to estimate your order is to start with pins per player.
Recommended: 15–20 pins per player
This gives players enough pins to trade across multiple days without running out too quickly.
Breakdown by Trading Level:

  • Light trading → 10–15 pins per player
  • Moderate trading → 15–20 pins per player
  • Heavy trading (major tournaments) → 20–25 pins per player

How Many Trading Pins Should a Team Order?

Here’s a simple guideline based on typical team sizes:

  • Small Teams (10 to 12 players)
  • Order: 150-200 pins
  • Medium Teams (12 to 14 players)
  • Order: 200-250 pins
  • Large Teams (14+ players)
    Order: 250-300 pins

Most teams choose 200–300 pins to be safe.

How Tournament Type Affects Quantity

Not all tournaments are the same.

Local Tournaments

  • Less trading activity
  • Fewer teams Order on the lower side

Travel / Regional Tournaments

  • Moderate trading
  • More variety of teams Standard order (200–250 pins)

Major Events (Like Cooperstown)

  • Heavy trading culture
  • Players trade daily Order more (250–300+ pins)

Do Better Designs Require More Pins? (Yes - Here’s Why)

Here’s something most teams don’t consider:
Better pins = more trades
If your pin includes:

  • Glitter
  • Spinners
  • Danglers
  • Unique shapes
    …it will be more desirable.
    That means:
  • Players will trade faster
  • You’ll need more pins

If you’re investing in premium features, it’s smart to increase your order slightly.
You can explore different design styles and features when you create your custom trading pins.

Should You Order Extra Trading Pins?

Short answer: Yes
Ordering extra pins gives your team flexibility.
Extra pins can be:

  • Saved as keepsakes
  • Given to coaches or family
  • Used for future events

Running out early is far worse than having a few extra.
Quick Answer (If You Just Want the Number)
If you want a simple, safe recommendation:
Order 200-300 trading pins per team
This works for:

  • Most team sizes
  • Multi-day tournaments
  • Moderate to high trading

Common Mistakes Teams Make

  • Ordering too few pins
  • Not considering tournament size
  • Ignoring trading intensity
  • Choosing basic designs (less trade value)

Final Thoughts

Trading pins are one of the most memorable parts of any tournament. Getting the quantity right ensures your team can fully enjoy the experience without running out too early or overspending. If you’re unsure, it’s always better to order slightly more, especially for larger tournaments.
You can also view real trading pin designs to get ideas before ordering.

Not sure how many pins your team needs?

Get a free custom design + quantity recommendation based on your team size and tournament.

Get Free Design